- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Mark Topic as New
- Mark Topic as Read
- Float this Topic to the Top
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Printer Friendly Page
General Discussions
Bitter ex owes me money - help
My bf and I split at the end of last year. (I am 36, he is 29)
During last year we had taken someone to court. Long story short is that he was awarded the payout as my employer and we agreed on a portion of that which he would pay to me monthly (as he is getting monthly instalments from the people we took to court). We were equal partners in the business but due to other details he took me on as an employee and he was my employer. So it was all done in his name but I was his working partner and witness in the court case. But because it was all done in his name the payment was awarded to him. He agreed to pay me my share.
Anyway - to the point - the first instalment was November which was received but ever since about the last 3 months I am having to chase him to remind him to pay me my share. He knows that I am an unemployed single mum and that I really need the money but he seems to be deliberately making things awkward.
Each payment that I have received has been when I have chased him up and he has paid it into my account over the counter at his local bank.
I have suggested more than once (and as recently as the other day) to set up a standing order so that he doesn't 'forget' and I don't have to chase him for it.
He could have set this up last month when he last paid me but he didn't because I text him 3 days ago to check. Now he says he is going into hospital today for a minor opertaion on his leg and will get around to it when he is mobile again. I reminded him that he doesn't have to go physically into the bank and that he could have set up a standing order anytime, by phone.
I got a text back saying he doesn't care and that he will do it when he 'gets chance'.
He owes me £1,750! and that is an awful lot of money to me and my son. He also knows that I have stryggled to get another job since the business went wrong last year and that is why I am still unemployed. But, regardless, he owes me that money whatever my circumstances.
What do I do? I have one friend saying that he is using this as a means of control, not wanting to cut the ties and knows that I will chase him up each month. She says I should cut my losses and don't chase him for the money anymore.
However, another couple of friends of mine think that I should continue to chase it up and turn up at his flat if I have to!
He says he doesn't want to see me because he is still angry and bitter so wouldn't it be easier all around if he just set up the standing order?
Why is he doing this to me? It is stressing me out each month and the knock on effect of what happened with my job and the court case and us splitting up (unrelated to the court case issue) is making me anxious every month when I know my payment should be due.
Please help and advise.
Sorceress
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Float this Topic to the Top
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
Bitter ex owes me money - help
My bf and I split at the end of last year. (I am 36, he is 29)
During last year we had taken someone to court. Long story short is that he was awarded the payout as my employer and we agreed on a portion of that which he would pay to me monthly (as he is getting monthly instalments from the people we took to court). We were equal partners in the business but due to other details he took me on as an employee and he was my employer. So it was all done in his name but I was his working partner and witness in the court case. But because it was all done in his name the payment was awarded to him. He agreed to pay me my share.
Anyway - to the point - the first instalment was November which was received but ever since about the last 3 months I am having to chase him to remind him to pay me my share. He knows that I am an unemployed single mum and that I really need the money but he seems to be deliberately making things awkward.
Each payment that I have received has been when I have chased him up and he has paid it into my account over the counter at his local bank.
I have suggested more than once (and as recently as the other day) to set up a standing order so that he doesn't 'forget' and I don't have to chase him for it.
He could have set this up last month when he last paid me but he didn't because I text him 3 days ago to check. Now he says he is going into hospital today for a minor opertaion on his leg and will get around to it when he is mobile again. I reminded him that he doesn't have to go physically into the bank and that he could have set up a standing order anytime, by phone.
I got a text back saying he doesn't care and that he will do it when he 'gets chance'.
He owes me £1,750! and that is an awful lot of money to me and my son. He also knows that I have stryggled to get another job since the business went wrong last year and that is why I am still unemployed. But, regardless, he owes me that money whatever my circumstances.
What do I do? I have one friend saying that he is using this as a means of control, not wanting to cut the ties and knows that I will chase him up each month. She says I should cut my losses and don't chase him for the money anymore.
However, another couple of friends of mine think that I should continue to chase it up and turn up at his flat if I have to!
He says he doesn't want to see me because he is still angry and bitter so wouldn't it be easier all around if he just set up the standing order?
Why is he doing this to me? It is stressing me out each month and the knock on effect of what happened with my job and the court case and us splitting up (unrelated to the court case issue) is making me anxious every month when I know my payment should be due.
Please help and advise.
Sorceress
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Float this Topic to the Top
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Float this Topic to the Top
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
Hi Sorceress,
I was once in a similar situation after having bailed someone out several times while we were together and then we split up with him owing me quite a bit of money. I too had to keep on and keep on at him to get my monthly payment. It really does drain you.
What I did was to phone him at work and the first person I spoke to I ended up telling why I needed to speak to him. I then got a reaction as although he was good humoured about it he wasn't pleased that I'd mentioned him owing me money at his work place.
It made a difference for a time but I never did get all of it back. In the end I had to write a portion of it off but I had got most of my money back.
Could you get a standing order form from the bank and complete as much of it as you can, get it to him somehow to sign it and then take it or ask him to send it to the bank ?
If he has online banking he could even arrange this online without anyone having to go to the bank.
Another possibility is to pay for a solicitor's letter asking for this money within a certain time limit or to have the standing order set up within a time limit. He may respond if he thinks you mean business.
Another option could be to threaten or casually mention the possibility of declaring him bankrupt due to the owing of this money and the reluctance in it being paid.
I'm not fully aware of all the ins and outs of doing this but I believe it is a possibility so maybe you could google for this and see if you can find something to add a bit of power to your endeavours.
Owly x
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Float this Topic to the Top
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
The court will regard someone as being unable to pay their debts if either of the following occurs:
A creditor who is owed more than £750 serves a 'statutory demand' for the money due and it is not paid or secured (for example, by a guarantee to provide something else of the same value); or a settlement is not agreed, within 21 days, and the debtor has not applied for the statutory demand to be set aside.
You can get the forms to issue a claim for judgment from your local county court. Court fees depend on the amount of the claim, and range from £35 to £1,670 - the court can tell you the precise court fee payable for a particular claim.
You can get the forms for a statutory demand from your local county court or a legal stationer:
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Float this Topic to the Top
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
Hi,
I am not sure where I stand legally. I didn't think that I have any leg to stand on because the court case and award was all in his name and not mine. The written paperwork from the judge awards the money to him; there is no mention of me.
Therefore, can I get a lawyer to send him a letter demanding money that was never officially awarded to me? I didn't think that I could.
I don't know where he works but what you did sounded good, like, shaming him into it. I could always communicate with his mum who was involved in helping with our case and she only lives up the road from him? I didn't really want to 'harass' his mum though but my options are running out.
I have already tried to get him to do the simple and obvious which is to set up a standing order and said he could even do it over the phone but he refused and said he will do it, in other words, when he is good and ready i.e. when he is next physically in the bank. I find it hard to believe him though because he said he was going to set up the standing order at the beginning of April and that never happened, he just pid the money in at the counter.
Sorceress
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Float this Topic to the Top
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
Hi,
Is there anything written or spoken anywhere, letter or text message or something on an answering machine where he has acknowledged owing you this money ?
If you have anything in writing then that might be enough.
I don't want to pry and you definitely don't need to say but it might help if I knew why you weren't named but were part of the intended recipient of the money ?
I didn't mean to imply that you went all the way to taking him to court etc but just putting a bit of a rocket up him to get him moving to do what you need him to do. Kind of scaring him about the possibility but I wouldn't want you to do anything that would jeopardise your overall receipt of the money or for him to turn nasty and stop giving you anything.
What you could really do with is someone who would chase this up regularly for you and keep on his back about it without you putting yourself through it. I'm not sure I can think of anyone or any organisation who would do that.
One thought I had was that he may not be reluctant to pay it each month by standing order or any other means, not because he's controlling (although that comes into it anyway) but that he's reluctant to let you go completely. To pay you off means to set you free and maybe a part of him isn't ready to do that yet.
Owly x
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Float this Topic to the Top
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
Found this...
Edited because I think this next link holds information that seems the best way to go....
Mediation in debt disputes
http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/MoneyTaxAndBenefits/Ma
These were the others that I found....
http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/moneytaxandbenefits/ma
The forms are on one of the headings.
The following makes for interesting reading but it is from 2003.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/2003/jun/15/consum
Owly x
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Float this Topic to the Top
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
Thanks Owly for all of your links.
The reason I wasn't mentioned in the judges award is because this guy was my bf but then became my employer when we took on the business. Plus, he was working full time and I was part time so we agreed that he was 'in charge' because he was there more often than me so it was all done in his name. Also, where we live, I need a work permit and he doesn't so it was easier for him to register as an employer and then apply for my permit for me on my behalf. (It's all legit! just a bit of a long winded story and doesn't really have much bearing on him owing me the money.) The amount he agreed to pay me from the award was less than half of it because he was full time and I was part time. I agreed to this because of the difference in hours worked.
I do have some text messages on my phone where we have discussed him paying me money but it talks about the amount paid to date and doesn't mention the full amount. Also some messages about when he is going to pay it in and set up a standing order etc. I also have bank statements with the amounts already paid from him since last November.
You are not the first person to mention that he might be doing this as a way of not letting go. We had a row at the end of last year and he left my house in a mood. He thinks that I have "wronged" him as he put it (another long story) and refuses to see me. During the last couple of months I have made it clear that I would like us to get together and talk, even if we could just maintain a friendship and clear up the misunderstandings.
He won't do this though and that is why I am confused. He says he doesn't want to see me and yet, like I say, you are not the first person to comment that he doesn't want to pay me and cut the ties completely. But what is he waiting for? If he doesn't want to see me then why prolong the situation? What exactly is he holding on to?
I feel really conflicted about what to do. I have one friend saying I should go to his place and 'give him what for' and an older friend telling me that would be madness and that I should remove his power over me by cutting my losses over the money and not chasing it any further.
Just the other day he now tells me that he wants to do these people (that we took to court) for tax evasion. He didn't keep any of the paperwork and asked me if I have any copies, which I do. However, when I said I would like to be involved he said it was no longer any of my business! I thought he had a cheek, especially since I lost my job overnite just like he did and went through the drama of court and as a witness I effectively won the case for him!
He texts me his new address (as he has moved from his mum's place to a flat just up the road from her). I would have thought that for someone who wants nothing to do with me that he wouldn't want to risk giving me his new address and would have asked me to send the paperwork to his mum's place.
Needless to say, I am not sending anything as he is giving me nothing but asking for everything and still wants my help.
I did call the Citizens Advice this morning. They said it will be slightly difficult if we don't have a written agreement between us and all I can do is continue to chase him up or call a lawyer and get a half hour of free advice.
Why can't he just do the simple thing and arrange the standing order?
He has even disclosed that he is on good money in a new job that he has started. When we won the case he said that when he got a job after losing the business that he would pay me out of his wages so I wouldn't have to wait so long for my share of the money as he knows my financial situation isn't good. Now he admits to being well paid and can't even pay me the basic £50 per month as per the agreement. It will take him 2 years and 9 months to pay me off. I can't be going through this every month for that long, can I?
Sorceress
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Float this Topic to the Top
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
Hi,
Yeah I see what you mean about it being complex and yet having no bearing on the outcome. I can see why things were done the way they were too. It doesn't really help me to come up with anything unfortunately.
I think anything on a text that indicates he owes you money that he's attempting to repay shows something because if it wasn't about this large amount what would that mean, that he also owes you for something else, possibly smaller that he's intending to pay. It wouldn't look good that there was the likelyhood of two debts he owes to you, the one you are claiming for the this 'other one'.
If he claims he's texting you about another debt then what's he doing about the larger one ?
I'm sure a good solicitor would be able to pick holes in any claims and excuses he came up with.
You know him better than anyone so would you say he had control freak tendencies or bears a grudge forever ?
He could just be a bit twisted as a result of feeling so 'wronged'. It might explain why he's just reluctant to give you what you are entitled to.
Be careful of him asking you for any paperwork relating to the case you both won. It could be that he needs to remove evidence from you so he can claim nothing is owed to you. I'd tell him that you've lost these papers and only found that out when you went to get them.
I smell a rat there. I could easily be wrong but it seems odd to me.
It is very strange that he text you his new address. He must like the idea that you can contact him. Maybe he wants you to be impressed and see what you've lost and missing out on.
The Citizen's advice was pretty run of the mill. It's like taking their most known responses to similar situations and relaying them to you.
I'd contact that mediation debt link that I posted as that seemed the best solution. Someone else getting involved for you and chasing it up or acting as mediator to set something up to smooth this payment along.
Maybe he's even hoping that you'll give up as it's all too much hassle and he'll feel chuffed that he's won something from you. A kind of payment for being 'wronged' if you like.
Owly x
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Float this Topic to the Top
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
Hi again,
I have since had my money for this month (on 2nd May) and he text me to say it was in my account and that he had set up the standing order. I didn't reply and 2 hours later I got another text from him saying "thanks like..." as if I should be bowing down and kissing his feet for something he should have sorted in November. I ignored that text too.
Yesterday, on a random moment, I went to visit him at his flat. I made out I was in the area anyway and had those papers with me (I didn't and don't worry, he ain't getting them either. If push came to shove he could always get a copy of the documents because they will be filed at the court.)
This was the first time we had actually seen each other since Christmas. He was very stand offish, very defensive. I only had about 15 mins as his friend was picking him up to go out. I said it's about time we talked but he said there was nothing to talk about but then went on about the issue he was moody about from last year. (my ex returning onto the scene). I then reminded him that at the end of last year when he asked me for an exclusive relationship, because I took a few days to get back to him (I was away visiting family) he sends me an email saying he can take the bad news and jumps into bed with someone else who he then dated until end Feb this year.
He said that he can't get past what happened with me and my ex on one occasion but I said it's the pot calling the kettle black and we weren't in a r'ship at that point. He said he can't get past it. He continued to be emotionally awry and defensive until his friend picked him up.
So I drove home and thought, well, I tried, and decided that he mustn't be interested in talking at all, in any capacity.
Then, 2 hours later he texts me and then texts me again just as I was going to bed.
I don't understand this.
By the way, his flat was no palace compared to where he was with his mum it was typical Man Flat i.e. complete tip.
It will also be interesting to see if I do indeed get my money next month on a standing order.
I still don't know why he insists he doesn't want to talk and then starts texting me again.
Sorceress
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Float this Topic to the Top
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report Inappropriate Content
Hi,
The man clearly has issues of some sort. He jumps to worst case scenario conclusions in seconds. Can hardly seem to wait or believe outcomes will be positive. He's also very defensive as a result of whatever issues or fears are lurking inside himself.
I think what can sometimes happen is that people with insecurities or past hurts that have made them vulnerable, they cover their pain with aggression, not necessarily physical aggression. They tend to place a false image of their own making over the facts and then don't see the facts as they really are. Instead they see some kind of hazy image where the two are merged, the fact and the fiction and they cannot be disuaded that what they are doing is wrong because they are doing it as a form of defence, of feeling they are protecting themselves from being as hurt as they had once been or prepared for betrayal in order to avoid it or at worse do the same back before it's done to them.
He has to realise that he isn't going to get reassurances immediately every single time. He opens himself up to being hurt, takes a risk by laying his feelings out or making a request and when he thinks it's going to be bad news he shuts himself up like a clam and inflicts pain before it can be inflicted on him.
To be honest I think unless he sees what he's doing he's unlikely to change and what he needs would be asking a lot of any woman. She would have to put herself out to make him feel better and he could end up taking it all and not doing any repair work on himself to save her from having to keep doing it.
He needs to recognise his own weaknesses and work on those.
He won't be able to 'get past' anything that a. has the potential to hurt him and b. enables him to use it as a weapon against the other person. He protects himself at the same time as he's increasing his control.
Perhaps after all this is all about control and when you have it he doesn't like it and when he gives you control he expects to be rewarded for it. Such as when he gave in and set up the standing order.
Owly x




